I was hearing in my mind academic voices saying things like “You pro-Israel people are denying the Historic Processes of Oppression and their endurance, you deny that, if not fought back somehow, these things persist in time, because of the System.”
Then I realized: they are the ones who are saying that
a people that has been persecuted through centuries until 6 million were
finally thrown into gas chambers, became the contrary in last than one hundred
years. They seem to be saying that those “Historic Structures of Oppression”
are very easily changed very quickly, right?
But wait, aren’t the Muslin Arabs historically
oppressed? Where? Let’s take Palestine then, for instance. When they were
historically oppressed there? In the centuries they lived under the caliphs or
the five hundred years they lived under the Sultans of the Ottoman Empire, or
the 28 years under Britain?
It was Muslins living under the rule of Muslins.
Unless you consider the Sultans part of the oppressed.
And the sheiks. But don’t you realize you will be calling men who smoke fancy cigars and have collections of luxury cars, and rivers of
petroleum, an oppressed group? Don’t you see how crazy this is?
This is the story of a people who were outcast and persecuted
everywhere, and another people who, if oppressed, were being oppressed by their
own leaders. Then finally the Ottoman Empire was over, and less than one
percent of the Middle East was given to the Jews after the genocide they
suffered. That less than one percent was in their Holy Land, the place they
prayed to return to, generation after generation.
In that map redefinition, Jews had to flee Arab
countries in a hurry not to be killed, Jews had to leave Europe, some after
their family had just been exterminated, and a group of Arabs had to flee the
part of Palestine that was given to the Jews. The number of displaced Jews in
the Middle East is at least as big as the Arabs.
A lot of sad aspects to it, but still a deal that was
fair enough, and the Jews were right to accept. They were right to not step
back when the Arabs said “no, we want to rule one hundred percent of the Middle
East, not ninety-nine and something”. Those Jews didn’t want to be forever without a land of
their own, and they had very good reasons for that. In their tradition, and in
their past and recent History.
They then had to fight for it, because Arab countries
attacked, seven nations against one, and the Jews miraculously won. And they
were attacked again, and again. After some time, the modus operandi of their
enemies was not so much open war anymore, but the funding of Terror Groups, so
these groups can attack and Israel supposedly can’t fight back, because these
group “are not” the countries, even when they rule a region like Gaza or a
piece of Lebanon.
Of course some people think, why armies? Why soldiers?
Why guns? I wish things were so simple that anytime you “spoke with someone
with open heart” you could completely avoid violence. But if that was the case,
we wouldn’t have so much violence all over the World. All over the World
countries need police, countries need armies.
Doesn’t the existence of this ideology that says
“Death to Israel” – in their own words, read the Hamas charter, listen to the
interviews of their leaders – doesn’t the existence of this ideology change the
reality? Doesn’t it make us think, well, Israel needs to take precautions,
there were thousands of Terror attacks, they need security measures, they need
to arrest people that throw stones – stones can kill, and that’s the intention
of the throwing. They need to check people who cross borders.
Isn’t it insane to be complaining about that instead
of thinking of how could the Palestinian people move away from this ideology?
How can anyone say Israel doesn’t want peace if their
enemies didn’t try peace yet even once?
Couldn’t they ever have tried nothing different?
Didn’t money get in there somehow? How much do a maze of large tunnels under
cities cost? Could it have been spent on something else?
Now, after the horrible massacre of October 7th,
Israel had to go to war. Imagine if the rulers of your neighbor country
commanded October 7th in your country. Imagine it happened closed to
your home. Wouldn’t you want to go after that group of people? Wouldn’t you
have to?
Now don’t use numbers to invert the logic. All that
happened later was war, and wars are not beautiful. Israel proves it don’t
target civilians. Israel offered peace many times through decades. The images
from Gaza, that’s what wars look like.
There is an evil campaign against Israel everywhere,
but the question we should be asking is simple: who should ask for the end of
this war?
Television showed people from Gaza say they don’t want bombings. Of course. I wish, and I am being sincere, that people in Gaza would say, “We don’t want any war with Israel, now or ever”.
Isn’t it a good first step for the changes people say they want, for the better of Palestinian people? They can’t say that because of that ideology. Because of Hamas.
It’s time for the World to show we don’t want to miss
the opportunity of seeing a Terror Group gone.
Television is mostly believing Hamas claims that they
didn’t break the ceasefire when Israel strikes, even when Israel shows videos
of Hamas violating the deal, but most journalist are “forgetting” to remind
people that Hamas agreed to put down their weapons. Isn’t this crucial for
peace?
So many people spent this entire time saying they
“differentiate the people of Gaza from Hamas”. Yes, let’s do this
differentiation, this separation, but not only in our little hearts, but in
reality. Free the people of Gaza from Hamas. What better opportunity than now?
This war is not what I wanted for the people of Israel
and the people of Gaza. But as I said, we need to get the people of Gaza to
say, “We want peace. Now and in the future. Gaza just wants to mind its
business”.
Nenhum comentário:
Postar um comentário